Monday, April 23, 2007

Harriet Miers: Backs Bush-Gonzales, Resigns

Harriet Miers and George Walker Bush
Miers: Gonzales shouldn't lose job because of firings

Former White House counsel's role in incident not clear

08:46 AM CDT on Thursday, April 19, 2007
TODD J. GILLMAN / The Dallas Morning News
tgillman@dallasnews.com
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/texassouthwest/stories/DN-miers_19nat.ART.State.Edition1.431dfb9.html

WASHINGTON – Harriet Miers, who recently left her job as White House counsel and returned to Dallas, said Wednesday that Attorney General Al Gonzales should keep his job despite allegations he bungled the firing of eight U.S. attorneys.

"I certainly think the attorney general should continue to serve," she said in a rare interview on the day she announced her next career move, a return to partnership at the law firm Locke Liddell & Sapp.

Mr. Gonzales will testify today to the Senate Judiciary Committee. He will try to dispel complaints that he was less than candid to lawmakers about the firings and that prosecutors were removed to make way for Bush loyalists or because of pressure stemming from politically tinged investigations.

"I'm sure the attorney general is prepared and equipped to respond fully to questions he'll be asked," Ms. Miers said.

Her role in the firings remains murky. As White House counsel, she initially suggested that Mr. Bush replace all 93 U.S. attorneys after his re-election, and she received copies of correspondence from Mr. Gonzales' underlings as the list was narrowed. But she hasn't spoken publicly about her input. And the White House is resisting demands for her testimony from Democratic-controlled congressional panels, citing executive privilege.

"Talk to the White House about those issues," she said.

In addition to a return to law practice, Ms. Miers wouldn't rule out a role running the Bush presidential library; Southern Methodist University – alma mater of Ms. Miers, the first lady and many others in the president's circle – is finalizing a deal with former Commerce Secretary Don Evans.

"I'll leave that to Don Evans and others that are working with the [library] foundation. ... I'm obviously a big fan and supporter of the president and Mrs. Bush and am very willing to serve if there's issues where I can be helpful," she said.

Harriet Miers returns to Texas law firm

http://washingtontimes.com/upi/20070420-111410-1410

Published: April 20, 2007 at 12:14 PM

DALLAS April 20 (UPI) -- Harriet Miers, former White House counsel and U.S. Supreme Court nominee, is returning to the Texas law firm she left for Washington six years ago.

Miers rejoins Locke Liddell & Sapp as a partner on May 1, associated with the firm's public policy and litigation group. She will be based in Washington, Dallas and Austin, the Fort Worth Star-Telegram reported Friday.

Jerry Clements, the current managing partner, said the firm is not concerned about possible political fallout from Miers' work at the White House or as a Supreme Court nominee when conservatives questioned her credentials.

Clements said that was viewed as "nothing more than politics


Sunday, April 22, 2007

Rove's Fingerprints and the Gonzales Fiasco

From U.S. News & World Report, April 20, 2007:
In the pitiful performance by Attorney General Alberto Gonzales in an attempt to save his job, the undercurrent of Karl Rove's role is obvious.

Rove has been behind about every act of political chicanery in President Bush's tenure and while Bush was governor of Texas.

How else can you explain Rove's missing E-mails that you can bet were incriminating to his part in the firings of eight federal prosecutors? Rove's fingerprints are all over this sorry episode.

He has orchestrated attacks on Democrats opposed to the war in Iraq. His message seems to be: Don't say they are unpatriotic but give strong hints of it. He has made no secret of his master plan to keep the GOP majority in place with whatever it takes.

That scheme took a nose dive last November, and this war could shatter Rove's dream for a long time.

Politics ain't beanbag, as one wag put it long ago. Some Democratic consultants can play hardball too. But Rove likes to go beyond the rough stuff.

Go back to Rove's early days in judgeship races in Alabama. One opponent said Rovewasn't just satisfied with your defeat. He wanted to destroy you in the process....

... If any Republican wants a consultant and strategist without a conscience, I've got your man.

Posted at 04:35 PM by John W. Mashek

http://www.usnews.com/usnews/opinion/mashekblog/archive/070420/roves_fingerprints_and_the_gon.htm


Friday, April 20, 2007

Gonzales: Just A Link in a Chain


From today's New York Times:

If Attorney General Alberto Gonzales had gone to the Senate yesterday to convince the world that he ought to be fired, it’s hard to imagine how he could have done a better job, short of simply admitting the obvious: that the firing of eight United States attorneys was a partisan purge.

Mr. Gonzales came across as a dull-witted apparatchik incapable of running one of the most important departments in the executive branch.

He had no trouble remembering complaints from his bosses and Republican lawmakers about federal prosecutors who were not playing ball with the Republican Party’s efforts to drum up election fraud charges against Democratic politicians and Democratic voters. But he had no idea whether any of the 93 United States attorneys working for him — let alone the ones he fired — were doing a good job prosecuting real crimes.

He delegated responsibility for purging their ranks to an inexperienced and incompetent assistant who, if that’s possible, was even more of a plodding apparatchik. Mr. Gonzales failed to create the most rudimentary standards for judging the prosecutors’ work, except for political fealty. And when it came time to explain his inept decision making to the public, he gave a false account that was instantly and repeatedly contradicted by sworn testimony.

Even the most loyal Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee found it impossible to throw Mr. Gonzales a lifeline. The best Orrin Hatch of Utah could do was to mutter that “I think that you’ll agree that this was poorly handled” and to suggest that Mr. Gonzales should just be forgiven. Senator Sam Brownback led Mr. Gonzales through the names of the fired attorneys, evidently hoping he would offer cogent reasons for their dismissal.

Some of his answers were merely laughable. Mr. Gonzales said one prosecutor deserved to be fired because he wrote a letter that annoyed the deputy attorney general. Another prosecutor had the gall to ask Mr. Gonzales to reconsider a decision to seek the death penalty. (Mr. Gonzales, of course, is famous for never reconsidering a death penalty case, no matter how powerful the arguments are.)

Mr. Gonzales criticized other fired prosecutors for “poor management,” for losing the confidence of career prosecutors and for “not having total control of the office.” With those criticisms, Mr. Gonzales was really describing his own record: he has been a poor manager who has had no control over his department and has lost the confidence of his professional staff and all Americans.

Mr. Gonzales was even unable to say who compiled the list of federal attorneys slated for firing. The man he appointed to conduct the purge, Kyle Sampson, said he had not created the list. The former head of the office that supervises the federal prosecutors, Michael Battle, said he didn’t do it, as did William Mercer, the acting associate attorney general.

Mr. Gonzales said he did not know why the eight had been on the list when it was given to him, that it had not been accompanied by any written analysis and that he had just assumed it reflected a consensus of the senior leaders of his department. At one point, Mr. Gonzales even claimed that he could not remember how the Justice Department had come to submit an amendment to the Patriot Act that allowed him to fire United States attorneys and replace them without Senate confirmation. The Senate voted to revoke that power after the current scandal broke.

At the end of the day, we were left wondering why the nation’s chief law-enforcement officer would paint himself as a bumbling fool. Perhaps it’s because the alternative is that he is not telling the truth. There is strong evidence that this purge was directed from the White House, and that Karl Rove, Mr. Bush’s top political adviser, and Harriet Miers, the former White House counsel, were deeply involved.

Yesterday, Mr. Gonzales admitted that he had not been surprised by five of the names on the list because he had heard complaints about them — from Republican senators and Mr. Rove.

In another telling moment, Mr. Gonzales was asked when he had lost confidence in David Iglesias, who was fired as federal prosecutor in New Mexico. His answer was an inadvertent slip of truth.

“Mr. Iglesias lost the confidence of Senator Domenici, as I recall, in the fall of 2005,” Mr. Gonzales said. It was Senator Pete Domenici of New Mexico, of course, who made a wildly inappropriate phone call to Mr. Iglesias in 2006, not 2005, to ask whether charges would be filed before the election in a corruption inquiry focused on Democrats. When Mr. Iglesias said he did not think so, Mr. Domenici hung up and complained to the White House. Shortly after, Mr. Iglesias’s name was added to the firing list.

We don’t yet know whether Mr. Gonzales is merely so incompetent that he should be fired immediately, or whether he is covering something up.

But if we believe the testimony that neither he nor any other senior Justice Department official was calling the shots on the purge, then the public needs to know who was. That is why the Judiciary Committee must stick to its insistence that Mr. Rove, Ms. Miers and other White House officials testify in public and under oath and that all documents be turned over to Congress, including e-mail messages by Mr. Rove that the Republican Party has yet to produce.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/20/opinion/20fri1.html


Monday, March 26, 2007

Police Subversion of 1st Amendment

See:

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/25/nyregion/25infiltrate.html?ei=5065&en=bd8e0dbbd9a8ffdb&ex=1175400000&partner=MYWAY&pagewanted=print

Bush-Gonzales Letters to the Editor


From The New York Times:


To the editor:

Re “The Failed Attorney General” (editorial, March 11)

Thank you for yet another superb editorial about the Bush imperial presidency. Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales is worthy of your criticism. Though I heartily applaud your recent series of editorials along those lines, they somehow remind me of artillery fire that has not yet found its proper target.

Explosions all around, but none hit the target.

The target is the USA PATRIOT Act and its cousin, the Military Commissions Act. They are the foundations and hallmark of this imperial presidency. He repeal mechanism serves an important purpose in our system of government, and both these laws should be repealed forthwith.

Richard Sinnott
Fort Pierce, Fla., March 11, 2007

To the editor:

One question has to be answered in order to replace Alberto R. Gonzales as attorney general: does the president know of any truly qualified candidates for attorney general who do not come from his group of enablers?

I, for one, have great misgivings about the answer, and personally doubt that it will be addressed soon.

If the president does nothing about this crisis, Congress must. We cannot afford any more erosion of our civil liberties or the Constitution.

Frances M. Hilton
Norway, Me., March 11, 2007

Monday, March 12, 2007

NY Sen. Schumer Calles for Gonzales to Resign

Sen. Schumer Calls For Alberto Gonzales To Resign

  • Today on CBS’s Face the Nation, Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) called on Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to resign. Schumer said Gonzales has “been even more political than his predecessor, Attorney General Ashcroft,” and that Gonzales “either doesn’t accept or doesn̵...
http://www.newscloud.com/read/81270

Schumer’s call echoes a New York Times editorial this morning. The Times examined Gonzales’ record beyond the U.S. Attorney purge and the FBI’s Patriot Act violations:

– Gonzales “repeatedly defended Mr. Bush’s decision to authorize warrantless eavesdropping on Americans’ international calls and e-mail.”

– Gonzalez “was an eager public champion of the absurd notion that as commander in chief during a time of war, Mr. Bush can ignore laws that he thinks get in his way.”

– Gonzales “was disdainful of any attempt by Congress to examine the spying program, let alone control it.”

– Gonzales “helped formulate and later defended the policies that repudiated the Geneva Conventions in the war against terror, and that sanctioned the use of kidnapping, secret detentions, abuse and torture.”

– Gonzales “has been central to the administration’s assault on the courts, which he recently said had no right to judge national security policies, and on the constitutional separation of powers.”

– Under Gonzales, the Justice Department “has abandoned its duties as guardian of election integrity and voting rights. It approved a Georgia photo-ID law that a federal judge later likened to a poll tax, a case in which Mr. Gonzales’s political team overrode the objections of the department’s professional staff.”

– Under Gonzales, the Justice Department “has been shamefully indifferent to complaints of voter suppression aimed at minority voters. But it has managed to find the time to sue a group of black political leaders in Mississippi for discriminating against white voters.”

Transcript:

SCHIEFFER: Senator Schumer, what do you think ought to be done about this situation?

SCHUMER: Well, Bob, you know, the Justice Department is different than any other department. In every other department, the chief cabinet officer is supposed to follow the president’s orders, request, without exception.

But the Justice Department has a higher responsibility: rule of law and the Constitution. And Attorney General Gonzales in his department has been even more political than his predecessor, Attorney General Ashcroft.

Attorney General Gonzales is a nice man. But he either doesn’t accept or doesn’t understand that he is no longer just the president’s lawyer, but has a higher obligation to the rule of law and the Constitution, even when the president should not want it to be so. And so this department has been so political that I think for the sake of the nation, Attorney General Gonzales should step down.

http://www.newscloud.com/read/81270



Sunday, March 11, 2007

NYT Editorial: The Failed Attorney General

During the hearing on his nomination as attorney general, Alberto Gonzales said he understood the difference between the job he held — President Bush’s in-house lawyer — and the job he wanted, which was to represent all Americans as their chief law enforcement officer and a key defender of the Constitution. Two years later, it is obvious Mr. Gonzales does not have a clue about the difference.

He has never stopped being consigliere to Mr. Bush’s imperial presidency. If anyone, outside Mr. Bush’s rapidly shrinking circle of enablers, still had doubts about that, the events of last week should have erased them.

First, there was Mr. Gonzales’s lame op-ed article in USA Today trying to defend the obviously politically motivated firing of eight United States attorneys, which he dismissed as an “overblown personnel matter.” Then his inspector general exposed the way the Federal Bureau of Investigation has been abusing yet another unnecessary new power that Mr. Gonzales helped wring out of the Republican-dominated Congress in the name of fighting terrorism.

The F.B.I. has been using powers it obtained under the Patriot Act to get financial, business and telephone records of Americans by issuing tens of thousands of “national security letters,” a euphemism for warrants that are issued without any judicial review or avenue of appeal. The administration said that, as with many powers it has arrogated since the 9/11 attacks, this radical change was essential to fast and nimble antiterrorism efforts, and it promised to police the use of the letters carefully.

But like so many of the administration’s promises, this one evaporated before the ink on those letters could dry. The F.B.I. director, Robert Mueller, admitted Friday that his agency had used the new powers improperly.

Mr. Gonzales does not directly run the F.B.I., but it is part of his department and has clearly gotten the message that promises (and civil rights) are meant to be broken.

It was Mr. Gonzales, after all, who repeatedly defended Mr. Bush’s decision to authorize warrantless eavesdropping on Americans’ international calls and e-mail. He was an eager public champion of the absurd notion that as commander in chief during a time of war, Mr. Bush can ignore laws that he thinks get in his way. Mr. Gonzales was disdainful of any attempt by Congress to examine the spying program, let alone control it.

The attorney general helped formulate and later defended the policies that repudiated the Geneva Conventions in the war against terror, and that sanctioned the use of kidnapping, secret detentions, abuse and torture. He has been central to the administration’s assault on the courts, which he recently said had no right to judge national security policies, and on the constitutional separation of powers.

His Justice Department has abandoned its duties as guardian of election integrity and voting rights. It approved a Georgia photo-ID law that a federal judge later likened to a poll tax, a case in which Mr. Gonzales’s political team overrode the objections of the department’s professional staff.

The Justice Department has been shamefully indifferent to complaints of voter suppression aimed at minority voters. But it has managed to find the time to sue a group of black political leaders in Mississippi for discriminating against white voters.

We opposed Mr. Gonzales’s nomination as attorney general. His résumé was weak, centered around producing legal briefs for Mr. Bush that assured him that the law said what he wanted it to say. More than anyone in the administration, except perhaps Vice President Dick Cheney, Mr. Gonzales symbolizes Mr. Bush’s disdain for the separation of powers, civil liberties and the rule of law.

On Thursday, Senator Arlen Specter, the senior Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, hinted very obliquely that perhaps Mr. Gonzales’s time was up. We’re not going to be oblique. Mr. Bush should dismiss Mr. Gonzales and finally appoint an attorney general who will use the job to enforce the law and defend the Constitution.

WP Editorial: The Right Way to Manage U.S. Attorneys

The Right Way to Manage U.S. Attorneys

Saturday, March 10, 2007; Page A19

The recent firings of eight U.S. attorneys and the revelations that politics may have played a role in the dismissals have focused a spotlight on this important and often ignored federal office. On all levels of government, prosecutors wield enormous power. Indeed, more than 60 years ago, Attorney General Robert Jackson, who went on to become a Supreme Court justice, noted that a U.S. attorney "has more control over life, liberty, and reputation than any other person in America."

The dismissals appear to have been politically motivated and carried out heavy-handedly; initially, doublespeak was used to explain what was done and why. The irony is that a president and his or her attorney general should seek a centrally coordinated and cohesive federal prosecution force. Without some attempt to organize the 93 federal judicial districts, each of which has its own U.S. attorney, inefficiency can be common across offices. Prosecutors might lack consistent priorities and vary on treatment of similar cases. With so much potential criminal conduct and too few resources in the form of investigators and prosecutors, an administration's law enforcement efforts can be diluted if goals are not coordinated.

The problem in recent years has been not that Washington is too involved in supervising these offices and their personnel but that it has done too little. Some U.S. attorneys will decide, say, to pursue drug and immigration cases while others pursue business or consumer fraud and still others seek public corruption cases (and the accompanying headlines). Some might adopt one set of policies for plea agreements and what sentences to seek for those cooperating with law enforcement, while others have different rules and practices. Practicing lawyers acknowledge that even though there is only one set of federal criminal statutes, one set of federal rules of criminal procedure and one set of sentencing guidelines, procedures often seem to vary depending on which U.S. attorney's office is involved.

The Bush administration's folly is not that it attempted to choose, supervise and coordinate outstanding attorneys who would adhere to the same priorities and practices but that near the end of its tenure it tried to regulate specific offices in specific investigations. There can be no disagreement about this: Once a U.S. attorney has been appointed, that person's particular investigations and cases must be totally off-limits to questions from the White House or anyone in Congress. There is simply too much room for any such inquiry to be (or to be perceived as) a request that a case be brought, or not brought, to allow any exceptions.

History is replete with "innocent" inquiries from members of Congress to the Justice Department that have sparked controversy and criticism, such as Rep. Joshua Eilberg's inquiry about a Philadelphia corruption case in 1978 and House Speaker Jim Wright's inquiries about Texas savings and loan cases in 1988. There have been too many incidents for that lesson not to have been learned.

Another irony is that U.S. attorneys are usually appointed on the recommendation of the senator or senators from the president's party as one of a new administration's key political plums. So from the outset, politics plays a role in who becomes a U.S. attorney. But preelection political interference, such as that by Sen. Pete Domenici and Rep. Heather Wilson, both New Mexico Republicans, who called their U.S. attorney in October about a public corruption case on which they hoped to see action, has caused some of the recent fury.

The recent blunders hold lessons for future administrations. First, the provision slipped into the extension of the USA Patriot Act last year, giving the president more authority to appoint interim U.S. attorneys without Senate approval, has to be revoked. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales just announced that he will support this. Confirmation hearings are one of the few ways in which this position is reviewed.

Second, the next president and attorney general should make an immediate priority of finding and selecting the best lawyer for each U.S. attorney position, even if it means seeking bipartisan, merit-based recommendations, as President Jimmy Carter and Attorney General Griffin B. Bell did, and forgoing political patronage for the favorite of a particular senator. In this, it is not only appropriate but essential that the president and attorney general find individuals who agree with the new administration's priorities, concepts of procedure (e.g., sentencing guidelines) and use of resources, as well as individuals who agree that the Justice Department has a vital role in supervising the 93 U.S. attorneys once they are confirmed.

Finally, once an attorney is chosen on the merits, screened at confirmation hearings and supervised on general priorities and principles, that U.S. attorney and the specific cases he or she works on must be immune to interference or the perception of interference by anyone in the White House or Congress. Any such inquiry, intentional or not, will always raise the specter of politics and favoritism -- two of the death knells to an independent judiciary.

The writer, a criminal and civil litigator in Washington, served as special assistant to the attorney general in the Carter administration.

U.S. F.B.I. Data Rape of the Masses (20,000+ and counting)

http://downwithtyranny.blogspot.com/2007/03/ny-times-calls-for-alberto-gonzales.html

The F.B.I. has been using powers it obtained under the Patriot Act to get financial, business and telephone records of Americans by issuing tens of thousands of “national security letters,” a euphemism for warrants that are issued without any judicial review or avenue of appeal. The administration said that, as with many powers it has arrogated since the 9/11 attacks, this radical change was essential to fast and nimble antiterrorism efforts, and it promised to police the use of the letters carefully.



Thursday, March 01, 2007

Pushing Out Justice

From http://www.americanprogressaction.org/progressreport/
March 1, 2007

One of the most "important tenets" of a U.S. attorney's office is to never "mix politics with prosecutions." But it appears that the Justice Department has done just that, recently firing eight well-respected U.S. attorneys and replacing them with partisan Bush administration loyalists. Many of these ousted prosecutors were working on high-profile corruption cases and received high marks on their job evaluations by the Justice Department. All appear to be "victim[s] of strong-arm political pressure from Washington," pushed out to make room for political cronies. At each turn, Justice Department officials have made up different excuses for the firings, from insisting that the prosecutors stepped down on their own to claiming that they were fired for "performance-related" reasons. None of these charges have stood up. A little-noticed provision in the Patriot Act allows these "interim" Bush appointees to serve indefinitely, without Senate approval. Conservative senators are now blocking a repeal of this measure. "I think Americans need to have full confidence that their federal prosecutors are above politics," said one of the ousted prosecutors, David Iglesias, highlighting why it is necessary for all of these Bush appointees to be held up to public scrutiny.

CLAIM #1 -- THEY WERE BAD AT THEIR JOBS:
On Feb. 6, Deputy Attorney General Paul McNulty testified to the Senate Judiciary Committee that six U.S. attorneys were fired in Dec. 2006 for "performance-related" reasons. But in reality, these prosecutors were highly respected in their fields and received praise in job evaluations from the Justice Department shortly before they were told to resign. Similarly, at least four of the fired prosecutors said that Michael Battle, head of the Executive Office of U.S. Attorneys, never cited performance issues -- or gave any reason at all -- as the reason for their forced resignations. John McKay, the former U.S. attorney in Washington, recounted his conversation with Battle: "When I was composed enough to ask him why [I was being fired], he told me he couldn't answer any of my questions. ... He said nothing about performance issues or management or anything else." In fact, five of these prosecutors had positive job reviews. Just months before firing him, Battle sent McKay a "congratulatory letter for the laudatory report issued by the Justice Department audit team." Daniel Bogden, the former U.S. attorney in Nevada, "was described in his last job performance evaluation in 2003 as being a 'capable' leader who was highly regarded by the federal judiciary and investigators." Former U.S. attorney in California Carol Lam was "'well respected' by law enforcement officials, judges and her staff" in her 2005 evaluation. Paul Charlton, former U.S. attorney in Arizona, was "described as being respected by his staff, federal investigators, judges and Native American leaders for 'his integrity, professionalism and competence.'" A Justice Department official also confirmed that Iglesias "received a positive evaluation last year."

CLAIM #2 -- THEY WEREN'T TEAM PLAYERS:
After media reports began revealing that the U.S. attorneys were all given positive job evaluations, the Justice Department changed its excuse for the forced resignations, claiming that the attorneys were rogue prosecutors. "The reviews don't take into account whether the U.S. attorneys carried out departmental priorities," said one official. But as the New York Times noted, "each case report included a statement that each of the ousted prosecutors had established strategic goals set by the Justice Department in high priority areas like counterterrorism, narcotics and gun violence." Bogden said that his office had "done more gun cases, drug cases, gang cases, child exploitation cases, identity theft cases than any office has done in any five year period of time." A Justice Department review of Iglesias's job performance, dated Nov. 2005, concluded that he had a strategic plan that "complied with the department's priorities."

CLAIM #3 -- THERE'S NO COVER-UP:
What the ousted prosecutors all have in common -- in addition to strong job evaluations -- is that they were "overseeing significant public-corruption investigations at the time they were asked to leave. Four of the probes target Republican politicians or their supporters." In the case that has received the most attention, Lam oversaw the public corruption case of former Rep. Randy "Duke" Cunningham, which resulted in his guilty plea and the indictments of a defense contractor and a former CIA official. With Lam's departure, it is unclear whether her successor will continue to pursue the corruption investigation. Similarly, Charlton's office was "investigating charges involving land deals and influence peddling against Republican Congressman Rick Renzi (R-AZ)," Bogden was "looking into campaign law violations by at least one member of the state's Congressional delegation," and Cummins was investigating Missouri Gov. Matt Blunt (R). Kevin Ryan, the former U.S. attorney in California, wasn't pursuing public corruption, but as Center for American Progress Senior Fellow Scott Lilly notes, he likely "stepped on the toes of a number of their [the Bush administration's] most generous contributors with his high profile investigations of back-dated stock options given to numerous executives in major corporations." Iglesias, who was pursuing a federal probe of a kickback scheme, believes he was fired because he "refused to speed up an indictment of local Democrats a month before November's congressional elections." Iglesias "said that two members of Congress called separately in mid-October" and "appeared eager...for an indictment to be issued before the elections in order to benefit the Republicans." "I believe that because I didn't play ball, so to speak, I was asked to resign," Iglesias noted.

CLAIM #4 -- IT'S NOT POLITICAL:
The Justice Department continues to insist that the firings weren't political. "I would never, ever make a change in the United States attorney position for political reasons," said Attorney General Alberto Gonzales. "When I hear you talk about the politicizing of the Department of Justice, it's like a knife in my heart," said McNulty. But the Justice Department itself has admitted that at least one of the U.S. attorneys -- H.E. "Bud" Cummings in Arkansas -- was pushed out to make way for Bush loyalist Timothy Griffin, the former research director at the Republican National Committee and a "37-year-old protege" of Karl Rove. According to Sen. Mark Pryor (D-AK), the Justice Department originally tried to claim that Cummins resigned on his own, which McNulty later admitted was untrue. Salon notes, "Some former Justice Department officials say they believe the administration's moves are a politically driven power grab -- aimed not only at a tighter grip on policy from Washington, but also at creating openings with which to reward their friends and build up a bench of conservative loyalists positioned to serve in powerful posts in future administrations." Similarly, Sen. John Ensign (R-AZ) was reportedly "told that the decision to remove U.S. attorneys, primarily in the West, was part of a plan to 'give somebody else that experience' to build up the back bench of Republicans by giving them high-profile jobs." Since last March, the administration has named nine U.S. attorneys -- including Griffin -- with Bush administration ties. These appointees include a former counselor to Gonzales and a protege of Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito.

CLAIM #5 -- IT WASN'T DONE TO AVOID CONGRESSIONAL OVERSIGHT: In 2005, a member of Sen. Arlen Specter's (R-PA) staff slipped into the Patriot Act a little-noticed provision that allows the attorney general to appoint replacement U.S. attorneys for an indefinite period of time. Earlier this month, the Senate Judiciary Committee approved a measure "that would take away the executive branch's unchecked power on U.S. attorney appointments" and restore the system to the pre-2005 rules. It would allow the attorney general "to appoint a replacement for 120 days, with the district court then stepping in and appointing a new interim U.S. attorney if the Senate has not approved a permanent one." Conservatives are now blocking the full Senate bill, sponsored by Sens. Patrick Leahy (D-VT), Dianne Feinstein (D-CA), and Mark Pryor (D-AR). Reps. John Conyers (D-MI) and Linda Sanchez (D-CA) requested an analysis from the Congressional Research Service (CRS) into whether previous administrations have also fired prosecutors without justification, but the Justice Department has refused to cooperate with the investigation, according to the CRS analyst. Today, the House Judiciary Committee is scheduled to vote on issuing subpoenas to four of the eight dismissed prosecutors and the Senate Judiciary Committee, meanwhile, "will send letters to those fired before voting next week on compelling their testimony." "In order to get the full picture of why these U.S. attorneys were fired, we need to hear from the Justice Department and the U.S. attorneys themselves," said Conyers.

An Executive Power of Establishing A Particular Religion?

Court hears religion case

Los Angeles Times

WASHINGTON — In a closely watched church-state separation case, a Bush administration lawyer urged the Supreme Court on Wednesday to shield the president's "faith-based initiative" from court challenges.

U.S. Solicitor General Paul Clement said taxpayers who believe the White House is unconstitutionally promoting religion should not be accorded legal standing to sue in court. It would be too "intrusive on the executive branch" to permit lawsuits contesting how the president and his advisers conduct their affairs, he said.

The case involves a Wisconsin group called Freedom From Religion that sued in 2004 to challenge the "faith-based initiative" on First Amendment grounds. The group said the White House officials were using public money to help church-based groups win grants and contracts.

It is the first major religion case to come before the Supreme Court since President Bush's two appointees — Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito — took their seats.

Overall, the nine justices seemed split during the hourlong argument. If they adopt the administration's view, the ruling could make it harder for critics to sue officials who use public money in ways that support religion. If the justices rule in favor of Freedom From Religion, the group would still have to prove its case in court.

Roberts made clear he thought the group's claims should be thrown out of court. If taxpayers can sue the government whenever an official invokes God or religion, why couldn't anyone "sue our marshal for standing up and saying, 'God save the United States and this honorable court'?" asked Roberts, citing the invocation heard each day when the justices enter the court.

But Justice Stephen Breyer said courts and lawsuits are needed to enforce the separation of church and state. "People become terribly upset when they see some other religion getting the money from the state" to subsidize their faith, he said.

Normally, people must say they have suffered a personal injury of some sort before they can sue in court. For example, taxpayers cannot sue to stop the war in Iraq simply because they disagree with it. But nearly 40 years ago, the court under then-Chief Justice Earl Warren made an exception for challenges to government spending that promotes religion.

A coalition of liberal groups filed a friend-of-the-court brief that urged the court to reject the administration's argument.

"Tax dollars may not be used to subsidize religious activity," said Steven Shapiro, the American Civil Liberties Union's legal director. "Barring taxpayers from enforcing this fundamental principle in court would effectively license the government to violate the Constitution."

The case will be decided in several months.

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/politics/2003594550_scotus01.html


(02-28) 19:08 PST WASHINGTON (AP) --

The Supreme Court wrestled Wednesday with the question of whether taxpayers have the right to challenge the White House's aggressive promotion of federal financial aid for religious charities.

At issue is whether a Wisconsin-based group of atheists and agnostics have legal standing, by virtue of being taxpayers, to bring their complaint in the federal court system.

Taking one extreme, Justice Stephen Breyer asked a lawyer for the White House whether a taxpayer would be able to challenge a law in which Congress sets up a church at Plymouth Rock.

"I would say no," responded Solicitor General Paul D. Clement, but he added that such a church could be challenged in other ways — just not on the basis that a taxpayer has been injured. Clement is representing the Bush administration, which is trying to prevent the taxpayer suit over its aggressive promotion, through the White House Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives, of federal financial aid for religious charities.

Taking the opposite extreme, Justice Antonin Scalia asked a lawyer for the Wisconsin group, Andrew Pincus, whether taxpayers would be able to sue over the use of security money for a presidential trip where religion is discussed.

Pincus said that taxpayers would not have standing to do so, arguing that in such a case the money spent would be "incidental," and not central to the issue.

The case may turn on a 1968 Supreme Court decision that created an exception to the general prohibition on taxpayer challenges to the government spending of tax revenue. In an 8-1 decision by Chief Justice Earl Warren, the court allowed taxpayers to challenge congressional spending for private religious schools.

But the Bush administration says spending for speeches and meetings of executive branch officials does not involve spending federal money outside the government and therefore taxpayers are not entitled to challenge it.

In the current case, the Bush administration organizes conferences where faith-based organizations are allegedly singled out as being particularly worthy of receiving federal money.

The group challenging the Bush administration, called the Freedom From Religion Foundation Inc., characterizes the White House's initiative as a singling out of faith-based organizations to the exclusion of other organizations.

Last year, a federal appeals court allowed the group to pursue its lawsuit. Instead of going through Congress, President Bush issued executive orders to create the White House office and similar centers in 10 federal agencies during his first term.

One of the goals Bush set for these offices was to help religious and community groups compete for federal funding to fight poverty, substance abuse and other social problems.

The 7th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in Chicago sided with the anti-religion group, and the Justice Department wants the Supreme Court to overturn the lower court.

The case is Hein v. Freedom From Religion Foundation Inc., 06-157.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2007/02/28/national/w165611S77.DTL&type=politics

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Bush-Gonzales: Prosecutors as Political Tools?

http://www.buffalonews.com/editorial/20070212/1033652.asp

WASHINGTON - The words of one of the greatest lawyers to work in Western New York were invoked last week in a Senate rebuke to the Bush administration's latest manipulation of the justice system.

The man was Robert H. Jackson, who went to school in the Jamestown area and practiced there in the early 1900s. Jackson became attorney general, a justice of the Supreme Court and, famously, the architect and first prosecutor at the war crimes trials in Nuremberg, Germany.

It would be a stretch to find much in common between today's Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and Attorney General Jackson of 1940.

Gonzales supports bypassing the Geneva Conventions on treatment of war prisoners, and warrantless eavesdropping on Americans. Most recently, Gonzales took steps to tighten the grip the White House holds on the corps of federal prosecutors nationwide.

A hearing chaired by Sen. Charles E. Schumer, D-N.Y., showed the Gonzales moves on U.S. attorneys had nothing to do with national security. They are designed to transform an elite group of lawyers into a political hackdom in Bush's last two years.

Schumer noted that in 1940 Jackson had lectured an assembly of U.S. attorneys on the necessity of their being absolutely nonpolitical. The reason, Jackson warned, was their great power.

"The prosecutor has more power over life, liberty and reputation than any person in America," Jackson said. "Because of this power to strike at citizens, not with mere individual strength, but with all the force of the government itself, the post has been safeguarded by presidential appointment requiring confirmation of the Senate."

Gonzales is using the amended Patriot Act to strip Senate confirmation and judicial safeguards from the selection process.

Without warning or apparent cause, Gonzales has fired seven prosecutors. Replacements could serve only 120 days without confirmation. Under the old law, a federal judge could name an interim prosecutor.

Now, replacements named by Gonzales can serve indefinitely without Senate action - at least through the end of Bush's term.

Many of the fired prosecutors were working on high-profile cases. The ousted San Francisco prosecutor, Kevin Ryan, was investigating stock options at Apple computer.

Most troubling was the sudden ouster of U.S. Attorney Susan Lam of San Diego. She had successfully prosecuted Republican Congressman Randy "Duke" Cunningham for taking more than a million dollars in bribes from defense contractors.

When Lam was jettisoned, she was weighing indictment of a Cunningham friend, defense contractor Brent Wilkes. Wilkes, people close to that case say, might lead prosecutors to other GOP House members for investigation.

Schumer asked Gonzales whether presidential adviser Karl Rove is involved in the process. The Justice Department admitted to Schumer in the hearing that the prosecutor for eastern Arkansas was removed to make way for J. Timothy Griffin, a former legal aide to Rove who also worked at digging up dirt on Democrats for the Republican National Committee.

Former prosecutors who testified at Schumer's hearing said Gonzales' actions could politicize operations in U.S. attorney offices all over the country.

"It is having a devastating effect on the morale of assistant U.S. attorneys," said Laurie Levinson, now a professor at Loyola Law School.

"Sudden replacement without apparent good cause can send the wrong message to other U.S. attorneys," said Mary Jo White, who headed federal prosecutions in Manhattan.

Schumer and congressional Democrats are pressing for a repeal of the suspect clause of the new Patriot Act.

e-mail: dturner@buffnews.com

Also, see:

http://takeitpersonally.blogspot.com/2007/02/conason-wakes-up-to-coup-detat.html


Joe Conason: Alberto Gonzalez's coup d'etat: dismissal and replacement
Posted by: "Dick Eastman" olfriend@nwinfo.net oldickeastman
Tue Feb 13, 2007 4:54 pm (PST)

http://www.salon. com/opinion/ conason/2007/ 02/09/united_ states_attorneys /index.html


Alberto Gonzalez's coup d'etat

The Constitution be damned, the attorney general has seized control of U.S. attorney appointments for partisan purposes.

By Joe Conason
Feb. 9, 2007

Under any circumstances, the Bush administration' s sudden, explicitly political dismissal and replacement of United States attorneys in judicial districts across the country would be very troubling - both as a violation of American law enforcement traditions and as a triumph of patronage over competence.

But as the story behind these strange decisions unfolds, a familiar theme is emerging. Again, the White House and the Justice Department have been exposed in a secretive attempt to expand executive power for partisan purposes. And again, their scheming is tainted with a nasty whiff of authoritarianism.

There is much more at stake here than a handful of federal jobs.

Leading senators of both parties are disturbed by these incidents because U.S. attorneys - the powerful officials appointed by the president to prosecute federal crimes and defend federal interests in each of the nation's judicial districts - are supposed to be as nonpartisan as possible. Democrats mostly appoint Democrats and Republicans mostly appoint Republicans, but the U.S. attorneys are usually chosen with the advice and consent of the senators from their home states, and then confirmed by the full Senate, with a decent respect for skill and experience as well as political connections.

The reason for this appointment process was simple: These prosecutors must police the politicians. They are expected to guard the nation's judicial system against the varieties of political abuse that are typical of authoritarian systems. They are granted a substantial degree of independence from the government in Washington, including the attorney general who functions as their boss.

To ensure that no U.S. attorney could be fired on a whim and replaced with a malleable hack, the relevant statute required that whenever a vacancy occurred in midterm, the replacement would be appointed by federal circuit judges rather than by the president. Getting rid of irksomely honest and nonpartisan prosecutors was difficult if not impossible.

But that wholesome safeguard was breached in December 2005, when the Senate renewed the Patriot Act. At the behest of the Justice Department, an aide to Sen. Arlen Specter slipped a provision into the bill that permitted the White House to place its own appointees in vacant U.S. attorney positions permanently and without Senate confirmation. So silently was this sleight of hand performed that Specter himself now claims, many months later, to have been completely unaware of the amendment's passage. (Of course, it would be nice if the senators actually read the legislation before they voted, particularly when they claim to be the authors.)

The staffer who reportedly performed this bit of dirty work is Michael O'Neill, a law professor at George Mason University and former clerk for Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas. As the Washington Times explained when O'Neill was appointed as the Senate Judiciary Committee's chief counsel, many observers believed that Specter had hired him to reassure conservatives of his loyalty to the Bush White House. Right-wing distrust had almost ousted the Pennsylvania moderate from the Judiciary chairmanship, and appointing O'Neill was apparently the price for keeping that post.

Evidently O'Neill rewarded Specter by sneaking through legislation to deprive him and his fellow senators of one of their most important powers, at the behest of an attorney general intent on aggrandizing executive power. The results of this backstage betrayal - now playing out in a wave of politicized dismissals and hirings - were perfectly predictable and utterly poisonous.

Carol Lam, the U.S. attorney in San Diego who successfully prosecuted the sensationally crooked Republican Rep. Randy "Duke" Cunningham, was fired for no known reason while she is still pursuing important leads in that historic case. Cunningham is supposed to be cooperating, but if Bush replaces her with a partisan stooge, he may be able to keep his secrets. Bud Cummings, the respected U.S. attorney in Little Rock, Ark., was canned to make room for a Republican opposition research operative and Karl Rove acolyte named Timothy Griffin. Could that conceivably have anything to do with Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton's presidential candidacy? Paul Charlton, the U.S. attorney in Arizona, was thrown out while investigating allegations of corruption against Republican Rep. Rick Renzi.

And John McKay, the U.S. attorney in Seattle whose diligence has been praised by judges and lawyers of both parties, was simply ordered to quit last December, for no obvious reason. Although McKay's last evaluation by the Justice Department was excellent, the attorney general insists that all of these curious firings were due to "performance" issues.

Any such self-serving statements emanating from Alberto Gonzales should always be greeted with appropriate skepticism. So should the claim that he sought to seize control of interim U.S. attorney appointments because of his concern over the "separation of powers" issues supposedly inherent in judges' appointing prosecutors. As the McClatchy Newspapers reported on Jan. 26, Gonzales has named at least nine "conservative loyalists from the Bush administration' s inner circle" to positions vacated by professional prosecutors.

On Thursday, the Senate Judiciary Committee voted to restore the old nonpartisan system for replacing U.S. attorneys and to require Senate confirmation of all new appointees. The full Senate and the House of Representatives should do likewise, despite Republican opposition, but that is not enough. The Senate Democrats should continue to probe the attorney general's little coup d'état and all of the resulting appointments. That is the best way to discourage future usurpations - and to frustrate whatever skulduggery was afoot this time.